PUBLIC HEALTH ASSESSMENT
ANDREWS AIR FORCE BASE
CAMP SPRINGS, PRINCE GEORGE'S COUNTY, MARYLAND
ATSDR identified the following community health concerns through meetings with concerned community members; contact with Andrews AFB, PGCHD, and EPA; and review of site documents.
Residential neighborhoods are located near the area on Foxley Road where the groundwater seep was discovered by PGCHD. Children may be incidentally exposed to the contamination if they play in that area and workers may be exposed during proposed road construction activities. To address this concern, ATSDR calculated conservative recreational and occupational exposure doses to the VOCs (i.e., chlorobenzene, 1,4-dichlorobenzene, 2-butanone, and acetone) and heavy metals (arsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, vanadium, and lead) that were detected in surface water and sediment from the seep. Please refer to Appendix B for further details concerning how ATSDR estimated exposure doses and determined health effects. The doses expected to result from incidental and occupational exposures to the water and sediment are not of health concern for children or construction crews because contaminant levels were too low.
ST-14 is the former East Side Service Station that is located in the northeast part of Andrews AFB, near the intersection of East Perimeter Road and Fetchet Avenue. The site was used to refuel and repair cars and store waste petroleum, oils, and lubricants in USTs. Groundwater contamination occurred around poorly constructed pipeline joints that caused several gas leaks and from activities at an aircraft maintenance shop, former hangar, and/or Base Fire Department. Three main plumes (TCE/DCE, carbon tetrachloride, and BTEX) originate from several source areas at ST-14. The carbon tetrachloride and BTEX plumes occur within the TCE/DCE plume and are located entirely on base.
According to sampling data from 1999 and 2000, the groundwater beneath Building Nos. 3462 and 3471 contains less than 100 ppb of TCE, less than 1 ppb of DCE, less than 1 ppb of carbon tetrachloride, and less than 25 ppb of benzene (the primary contaminant of concern in BTEX) [Andrews AFB 1999b, IT Corporation 2000b]. Plume maps from 1994 estimated the maximum concentration of TCE to be 1,000 ppb (Dames & Moore 1994b). The carbon tetrachloride and benzene plumes were not delineated under Building Nos. 3462 and 3471 in 1994. Using conservative screening techniques and the highest detected concentrations beneath the buildings, ATSDR predicted probable inhalation exposures to indoor air concentrations of TCE, DCE, carbon tetrachloride, and benzene that could have volatilized from the groundwater and entered the air within the buildings (EPA 1999). The resulting indoor air concentrations were too low to be of health concern. In addition, exposures are no longer possible at Building 3462 because it was torn down in January 2001.
It should first be noted that none of the toxicologic studies have shown clear evidence that inhalation of TCE is linked to increased in cancer risk (ATSDR 1997). ATSDR evaluated this concern on the basis of the potential for any health effects to result from exposure to the expected indoor air concentrations.
The trailer (building No. 47) is located near ST-14 where three groundwater plumes have been found. The 1994, 1999, and 2000 plume maps for Andrews AFB suggest that groundwater contamination is not located beneath the trailer (Andrews AFB 1999b; Dames & Moore 1994, IT Corporation 2000b). However, because the isoconcentration lines were estimated for this end of the plume in 2000 and concentrations were conflicting between the direct-push and monitoring well data in 1994, the reported extent of groundwater contamination did not conclusively rule out the potential for contamination to extend under the trailer. Therefore, using very conservative assumptions, ATSDR calculated probable inhalation exposures to indoor air using the highest concentration of TCE detected at ST-14 (2,500 ppb) [Andrews AFB 1999b]. This concentration was actually detected over 1,200 feet away from the trailer. Based on this assessment, ATSDR concludes that the resulting indoor air concentration would be too low to be the cause of adverse health effects, including leukemia, in workers (EPA 1999).
The 4-acre POL Storage Yard is located along the southeastern border of Andrews AFB on East Perimeter Road. The site consists of eight ASTs, 11 USTs, two pumping stations, two oil/water separators, an unused washrack area, a laboratory, and a main office. SS-13 has received, stored, and distributed petroleum since 1944. Throughout operation several fuel spills and leaks occurred causing soil and groundwater to be contaminated. Free product exists at the POL Yard in the vicinity of the Northern Pump Station and along the Steuart Petroleum pipeline. In 1995, it was reported that a plume of contamination extended slightly off base across Leapley Road, with benzene as the primary contaminant of concern (Tetra Tech 1995). In 1993, a free product removal system was installed in the vicinity of the source area (Northern Pump Station) to eliminate petroleum contamination. In 1995, a vacuum-enhanced pumping system was installed to remove free phase hydrocarbon from shallow groundwater. By 1998, the system had removed 5.3 million gallons of contaminated groundwater (USAF 1998). Groundwater gauging results have indicated that a groundwater ridge exists at the base boundary with the plume located on the opposite side of the residential neighborhood. Monitoring in 1997 and 2000 confirmed that the benzene plume is moving west and is now located entirely on base (PEER Consultants 1997, IT Corporation 2000a).
All of the 20 residences that are located within 800 feet of the POL Storage Yard are supplied with public water from WSSC (PGCHD 1992b; Tetra Tech 1995). A well survey performed in 1994 identified six commercial wells and three residential wells within 1.25 miles of the POL Storage Yard (Tetra Tech 1994). Another residential well survey reported that 11 private wells existed in the immediate vicinity of the POL Storage Yard, however, only one well appeared to be in use--for watering pets and washing cars (Tetra Tech 1995).
Based upon this information, residents near the POL Storage Yard do not need to be concerned for their health. Since the benzene plume does not extend past the Andrews AFB boundary into the housing area (PEER Consultants 1997, IT Corporation 2000a), exposures to both soil gas vapors and groundwater are not occurring. Additionally, residences in the vicinity are being supplied with public water and are not ingesting groundwater as their drinking water supply.
Since the plume did extend off base in the past, the potential for exposure could have occurred. However, none of the private groundwater wells identified were located within the confines of the plume, therefore, no one was drinking or using benzene-contaminated groundwater. It is possible that one or two of the trailers located immediately outside the boundary of SS-13 (in Flower Village) were above the plume when it extended off base. The expected concentration of benzene in the off-base groundwater was, however, very low (less than 100 ppb). ATSDR used conservative screening techniques to predict probable inhalation exposure to indoor air concentrations of benzene that could have volatilized from the groundwater and entered the air within the trailers (EPA 1999). Even if trailers were located above the confines of the benzene plume, the resulting indoor air concentrations would have been too low to be of health concern.
Some of the housing units at Andrews AFB do contain lead-based paints. The Air Force has identified the locations of these housing units and has a program to notify on-base residents of the possible presence of lead-based paints in their homes (e.g., residents are given a handout from the Base Housing Office). Residents must also initial a paragraph in the contract that states that they were notified of the potential presence of lead-based paints (Andrews AFB 2001a). ATSDR suggests that the notification include information on proper procedures to follow and who to contact if accessible lead-based paints are suspected.
Through the housing maintenance program, periodic comprehensive surveys of housing units are performed for the purpose of detecting and repairing any peeling or chipping paint (Andrews AFB 2001a). Proper monitoring and maintenance eliminates much of the potential hazard. If the paint is not accessible, then no exposure can occur.
Andrews AFB also has a blood lead screening program in place that screens for any potential exposure to lead; not just exposure from living in homes with lead-based paint (Andrews AFB 2001a). Until 1999, the Air Force conducted a universal blood lead screening program that tested each child as he or she arrived on base and each baby born on base at 18 months of age. Up to that time more than 98% of the children tested were negative for elevated blood lead levels (i.e., less than 10 micrograms per deciliter [mg/dl]); thereby, qualifying Andrews AFB to use a risk-based screening program instead of screening each child (IERA/RSRH 1999). The Air Force's new Child Blood Lead Screening Program tests all 12-month-old babies and those children who are at risk for lead exposure. Risk is determined through the parents completing an exposure assessment form. Thorough notification to the residents about the potential for lead-based paint in their homes ensures that the existing blood lead screening program is effectively used by the parents.
All of the groundwater plumes at Andrews AFB are briefly addressed in this public health assessment under the "Groundwater Contamination" section in the third pathway: Groundwater. The only two plumes that were identified to potentially impact off-site residents were a VOC plume from LF-05 (Leroy's Lane Landfill) and a potential petroleum plume from SS-11 (Davidsonville Fuel Oil Spill). All other groundwater plumes were located entirely on Andrews AFB and; therefore, cannot adversely impact residential groundwater wells.
For more information concerning these two sites, please read the Groundwater Pathway discussion.
Piscataway Creek exits Andrews AFB on the east-southeast border and flows south and southwest for about 13 miles before flowing into the Potomac River. Sections along these 13 off-site miles are used for recreation. Piscataway Creek potentially receives contaminants from several IRP sites that are located at its headwaters (FT-03, FT-04, LF-05, LF-06, LF-07, and AOC-27). Surface water, sediment, and fish from Piscataway Creek were sampled in 1993, and surface water and sediment were again tested in 1994. Various VOCs, SVOCs, pesticides, and metals were detected.
ATSDR concluded that no one is being harmed by contamination originating at Andrews AFB while recreating along Piscataway Creek because none of the detected chemicals were found at levels of health concern. This includes an evaluation of potential exposure as a result of participating in activities such as swimming and catching and eating fish up to 7 meals a month. For further details concerning Piscataway Creek please read the "Potential exposure of recreational users to contamination in Piscataway Creek" discussion in the Surface Water and Sediment Pathway.
ATSDR recognizes that infants and children may be more sensitive to environmental exposure than adults in communities faced with contamination of their water, soil, air, or food. This sensitivity is a result of the following factors: 1) children are more prone to be exposed to certain media (e.g., soil or surface water) because they play outdoors; 2) children are shorter than adults, which means that they can breathe dust, soil, and vapors close to the ground; and 3) children are smaller, therefore childhood exposure results in higher doses of chemical exposure per body weight. Children can sustain permanent damage if these factors lead to toxic exposure during critical growth stages. ATSDR is committed to evaluating their special interests at sites such as Andrews AFB as part of its Child Health Initiative.
In the past, children could have been exposed to harmful levels of lead in the soil surrounding two lead-paint containing water towers that were sandblasted in 1990/1991. An elevated blood lead level was documented for one child living near water tower No. 3589. Other children living or playing in the area may have had similar exposures. Currently, children playing near water tower No. 4614 may be exposed to elevated levels of lead in the soil. Sampling was recently conducted to define the nature and extent of the level of lead. The results are not yet available for review, however, preliminary evaluations from the Air Force's sampling suggest that the extent is limited. Once results are available, ATSDR will evaluate the effect of this exposure on children's health.
Andrews AFB established a childhood blood lead surveillance program in 1993 as required in the Department of Air Force Lead Screening Policy from HQ, April 2, 1993. The Public Health Flight reports statistics on blood lead screening to the Epidemiology Division at Armstrong Laboratories, Brooks AFB, TX. In 1996, Armstrong Laboratories analyzed the blood lead data and determined that Andrews AFB could move from universal screening to risk-based screening based on the statistically low percentage of elevated blood lead tests (IERA/RSRH 1999). All children attending the Pediatrics and Family Practice clinics are screened at their well-baby and annual check-ups via a questionnaire administered to the parents. The parents are also educated on lead exposures by their health care providers. Children whose activities, behaviors, or residence indicate a potential for lead exposure have their blood drawn to screen for elevated blood lead levels. Since 1994, 4,895 children have been screened. The Public Health flight investigates any blood lead levels elevated above 9 mg/dl to identify potential hazards/exposures. Since 1994, 99.37% of all tests were negative (98% is required to transition from universal to risk-based screening).
ATSDR did not identify any other pathways at Andrews AFB that could result in harmful exposures to children. ATSDR based this conclusion of the following factors:
ATSDR has drawn the following conclusions from current environmental data and information on the Andrews AFB site:
The Public Health Action Plan for Andrews AFB contains a description of actions taken and those to be taken by ATSDR, the Air Force, and PGCHD at and in the vicinity of the site after the completion of this public health assessment. The purpose of the Public Health Action Plan is to ensure that this public health assessment not only identifies public health hazards, but also provides a plan of action designed to mitigate and prevent adverse human health effects resulting from exposure to hazardous substances in the environment. The public health actions that are completed, being implemented, planned, or recommended are as follows:
Actions Completed:
Actions Ongoing:
Actions Planned:
Recommendations for Further Action:
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR). Toxicological profile for Trichloroethylene. Atlanta: US Department of Health and Human Services. September 1997
ATSDR. Toxicological profile for Lead. Atlanta: US Department of Health and Human Services. July 1999.
ATSDR. 2001. Public Health Assessment for Brandywine Defense Reutilization and Marketing Office. May 1, 2001.
Ahern, Col Daniel B, 89th AW/CC. 1992. Decision Document: Site FT-03, Fire Training Area 2, Andrews Air Force Base (AFB). September 25, 1992.
Andrews AFB, 89th AW/CC. 1991. Data sheet concerning contamination at 290 Winston Road. Andrews AFB, MD. 1991.
Andrews AFB, Installation Restoration Program (IRP). 1993. Assessment of Impacts of Landfills LF-06 and LF-07 on Piscataway Creek and Surrounding Area. December 1993.
Andrews AFB, 89 CES/CEVR. 1996. Decision Document for No Action at Sites LF-06 and LF-07, Andrews AFB. April 1996.
Andrews AFB.1997. Management Action Plan. July 1997.
Andrews AFB. 1999a. Draft Community Relations Plan. December 1999.
Andrews AFB, IRP. 1999b. Status Report: Supplemental Remedial Investigation, IRP Site ST-14. December 1999.
Andrews AFB. 2001a. Review Comments to ATSDR's Initial Release Draft Public Health Assessment for Andrews Air Force Base (December 2000). January 31, 2001.
Andrews AFB. 2001b. Excel data tables for the April surface soil sampling surrounding water tower Nos. 3589 and 4614. May 22, 2001.
Dames & Moore, Inc. 1992. Hazardous Waste Remedial Actions Program (HAZWRAP). Groundwater Contamination Survey, Andrews AFB. Bethesda, MD. April 1992.
Dames & Moore, Inc. 1994a. HAZWRAP. Technical Memorandum of Findings: Site ST-08 Investigation, Andrews AFB. Bethesda, MD. November 1994.
Dames & Moore, Inc. 1994b. HAZWRAP. Technical Memorandum of Findings: Site ST-14 Investigation, Andrews AFB. Bethesda, MD. November 1994.
EA Engineering, Science, and Technology, Inc (EA Engineering). 1993. U.S. Air Force. Human Health Risk Assessment, Andrews AFB, Family Housing Unit UST Leak. Loveton, MD. January 20, 1993.
EA Engineering. 1995a. Andrews AFB, CES/CEVR. Piscataway Creek Remedial Investigation Phase II Report, Volumes 1 and 2. Sparks, MD. April 1995.
EA Engineering. 1995b. Final Environmental Assessment for the Construction of an Eighteen-Hole Golf Course at Andrews AFB, Maryland. Sparks, MD. August 1995.
EA Engineering. 1995c. Letter to Mr. Terry Edwards from John Gurley concerning additional investigative work in support of the proposed golf course. Hunt Valley, MD. September 13, 1995.
EA Engineering. 1996. Army Corp of Engineers. Remedial Investigation Report, Leroy's Lane Landfill, Andrews AFB. Volumes 1 and 2. Sparks, MD. April 1996.
EA Engineering. 1996. Army Corp of Engineers. First-Quarter Field Sampling at Leroy's Lane Landfill (LF-05), Andrews AFB. Sparks, MD. February 1999.
Engineering-Science. 1985. U.S. Air Force AFESC/DEV. Phase I - Records Search. Andrews AFB, MD. June 1985.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 1997. Exposure Factors Handbook. August 1997.
Available at URL: http://www.epa.gov/ncea/exposfac.htm
.
EPA. 1999. Subsurface Vapor Intrusion into Buildings: User's Guide for the Johnson and Ettinger
(1991) Model and Models. January 14, 1999. Available at URL:
http://www.epa.gov/superfund/programs/risk/airmodel/johnson_ettinger.htm
.
Gannett Fleming, Inc./Dynamac Corporation. 1997. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region III. Data Acquisition Summary Report: Andrews AFB. December 30, 1997.
Government of District of Columbia (DC), Department of Human Services. 1991a. Blood Lead Levels. March 1991.
Government of DC, Department of Human Services. 1991b. Blood Lead Levels. May 1991.
IERA/RSRH. 1999. Letter to 89 MDG/CC from Major Steven R. Hinten concerning pediatric blood lead screening program testing status. Brooks AFB, TX. May 11, 1999.
IT Corporation. 1996a. Tennessee Center for Research and Development. Phase II Site Investigation Report, 2132 Richmond Drive Site 18 (ST-18), Andrews AFB, MD. Knoxville, TN. July 1996.
IT Corporation. 1996b. Tennessee Center for Research and Development. Phase II Site Investigation Report, Buildings 1950/1951, Site SS-21, Andrews AFB, MD. Knoxville, TN. July 1996.
IT Corporation. 1997. Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence. Interim Remedial Action/Treatability Study Report: ST-08, Military Gas Station. Knoxville, TN. March 1997.
IT Corporation. 1998. Letter to Mr. Ruiz-Vazquez from Everett Wessner concerning analytical data for the groundwater sampling at off-site locations at Andrews AFB. Knoxville, TN. January 21, 1998.
IT Corporation. 2000a. Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence. Quarterly System Evaluation Report (January through June 2000), Long-Term Monitoring/Operation and Maintenance Program at Multiple Sites at Andrews Air Force Base, Maryland. Knoxville, TN. November 2000.
IT Corporation. 2000b. Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence. Final Comprehensive Environmental Investigation at Site ST-14, Andrews Air Force Base, Maryland. Knoxville, TN. December 2000.
Maryland Department of the Environment (MDE). 1984. Field Investigation Report by Rich Maurer. Annapolis, MD. May 24, 1984.
MDE. 2000. Notice of Compliance from John Smiechowski to Col. Hawkins concerning SS-12. Baltimore, MD. June 15, 2000.
MITRE. 1993. Review of Investigations at Site LF-05, Andrews AFB, Camp Springs, MD. 1993.
PEER Consultants, P.C. 1997. Environmental Analytical Data: Informal Technical Information Report for the POL Storage Yard, Site SS-13, Andrews AFB, MD.
Penniman & Browne, Inc. 1990. Report of Analysis for lead levels in paint chips. Baltimore, MD. April 28, 1990.
Prince George's County Health Department (PGCHD). 1992a. Letter to Main File from Anne Williams concerning a survey of civilian drinking water supplies adjacent to Andrews AFB bulk fuel storage facility. August 19, 1992.
PGCHD. 1992b. Letter to Mr. Jim Rowell from Melanie Christodoulou concerning sampling at 6600 Foxley Road. Lanham-Seabrook, MD. August 27, 1992.
PGCHD. 1997. Letter to Ms. Margolis from Donald Nork concerning the Feasibility Study Report for LF-05. Landover, MD. May 2, 1997.
PGCHD. 2000. Certificate of Analysis - Volatiles concerning contamination from a groundwater seep on Foxley Road. Baltimore, MD. August 14, 2000.
PGCHD. 2001. Comments to ATSDR's Draft Public Health Assessment for Andrews AFB. February 28, 2001.
PGCHD. 2001. Comments to ATSDR's Public Comment Public Health Assessment for Andrews AFB. August 20, 2001.
State of Maryland, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. 1990. Metals Analysis Report Forms concerning contamination at water towers No. 3589. Baltimore, MD. December 1990.
State of Maryland, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. 1991a. Metals Analysis Report Forms concerning contamination at water towers No. 4614. Baltimore, MD. February 1991.
State of Maryland, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. 1991b. Dust Examination for Lead. Baltimore, MD. May 1991.
State of Maryland, Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. 2000. Metals Analysis Report Forms concerning sampling at 6600 Foxley Road. Baltimore, MD. August 30, 2000.
Tetra Tech, Inc. 1994. IRP RCRA Facility Investigation/Corrective Measures Study Work Plan for Site SS-13, POL Storage Yard, Andrews AFB, MD. San Bernardino, CA. March 1994.
Tetra Tech, Inc. 1995. Decision Document: Site SS-13, The Petroleum, Oil, and Lubricant Storage Yard, Andrews AFB. San Bernardino, CA. September 29, 1995.
Tetra Tech, Inc. 1996. Headquarters Air Mobility Command. Preliminary Assessment and Site Investigation Report: AOCs 23-25, 27-29, and IRP Sites FT-02, FT-03, SS-12, and WP-16. Falls Church, VA. July 1996.
United States Air Force (USAF). 1984. Letter to Charles Wheeler from Colonel Charles Ridgway concerning Notice of Violation C-84-758. Andrews AFB, DC. June 28, 1984.
USAF. 1998. Summary of Current and Planned Environmental Activities at IRP Sites: SS-13 (POL Yard) and SS-22 (Hangar 13). Presented to the Andrews AFB Technical Review Committee on July 23, 1998.
United States (U.S.) Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Division. 1989. United States Air Force. Installation Restoration Program Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study (RI/FS), Stage 1. Richmond, VA. April 1989.
U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). 1997. Preventing Iron Poisoning in Children. FDA Backgrounder. January 15, 1997. Available from URL: http://vm.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms.
Walter Reed AMC, MD. 1990. Blood Lead Levels. October 1990.
Jeff Kellam
Environmental Health Scientist
Federal Facilities Assessment Branch
Division of Health Assessment and Consultation
LCDR Danielle DeVoney, Ph.D.
Environmental Health Scientist
Federal Facilities Assessment Branch
Division of Health Assessment and Consultation
Gary Campbell, Ph.D.
Environmental Health Scientist, Section Chief
Federal Facilities Assessment Branch
Division of Health Assessment and Consultation
Next Section Table
of Contents