APPENDICES

Appendix A.  Particulate Matter Quality Assurance/Quality Control Discussion

General Notes on Quality Assurance/Quality Control Procedures

Quality assurance/quality control (QA/QC) procedures are used to ensure  the precision, accuracy, completeness, representativeness, comparability, and method detection limit of the results. The co-located samples and blanks are a primary means of assessing each of the data quality indicators. Comparing the results of two co-located samples provides information on the precision of the results as a whole. Comparing sample results to their associated blanks can help identify some potential errors in accuracy. Comparing the results received to those expected and necessary to draw conclusions about the data can help in understanding the completeness and reliability of the results. Comparability can be assessed by looking at the results taken from different sampling locations of the same buildingor from different buildings for the same type of location. The reviews are generally qualitative and provide a qualitative assessment of how well the data actually represents the sampled location.

The method detection limit is a more quantitative review. It is accomplished by calculating the lowest result the analytical method can accurately identify. It is based on an analysis of the blank samples and is specific for the sampling/analysis method. Reliable information can only be obtained from sample results with method detection limits significantly lower than the average value of the results and significantly lower than any comparison values to which the sample results will be compared.

The analytical results of the concentration of airborne particulate matter were provided by the laboratory as the initial weight of the filter prior to the sampling event and the final weight of the filter after the sampling event. The concentration of the particulate matter was calculated by dividing the weight of the material collected on the filter by the volume of air drawn through the filter by the pump using the following formulas.

Weight Gain of Filter = Final Weight Initial Weight

Sample Volume = Average Pump Flow Rate Sample Collection Time

Average Air Sampling Pump Flow Rate=(Presampling Flow Rate + Postsampling Flow Rate) 2

Concentration = Weight Change Sample Volume

Airborne Particulate Matter Sample Results

Each area that was sampled for airborne asbestos was also sampled for airborne particulate matter (PM). The sample results from the PM measurements did not meet the data QA/QC objectives. A variety of statistical and graphical analyses were performed on, and with, the measured results in an attempt to identify the cause and extent of inconsistencies of the measured results. A subset of the measured results that are not potentially affected by these inconsistencies were not identified. Therefore, the entire data set describing airborne particulate matter concentrations was rejected. In addition, the specific cause of the inconsistencies was not identified. The following information explains why the airborne particulate matter results were rejected.

Ideally, the particulate matter data would have provided information about the airborne concentration with an aerodynamic diameter of 100 microns and less (PM100), of 10 microns and less (PM10), of 4 microns and less (PM4), and of 2.5 microns and less (PM2.5). These different size fractions (PM100, PM10, PM4, and PM2.5) are collected using slightly different equipment, but following the same basic procedures. A pump draws air into a sampling head, and size specific particulate matter is deposited onto a filter. The difference in filter weight, before and after the sampling, represents the mass of the particulate matter that was captured by the filter. Knowing the presampling and postsampling air flow rates of the pump and the time duration for sample collection allows us to calculate the average volume of air that was drawn through the filter. The concentration of the size fraction in the sampled air is then calculated by dividing the PM mass by the air volume sampled.

In addition to the filters that were used to measure the concentration of airborne particulate matter, the laboratory also sent filters to be used as field blanks. Two blanks were sent for each PM fraction for each of the two sampling teams for each building. The blanks traveled with the sample filters, went to the sampled building or area, and were treated just like the sample filtersexcept that they were not used. Ideally, there should be very little difference in the weight of the blanks before the sampling and after the sampling because they were not used.  A weight gain in field blanks may indicate improper sample handling in the field or problems in filter weighing in the lab.  For the latter a decrease in post field blank filter weight is also an indication of lab weighing error.

The graph shown with this discussion shows the frequency distribution of the air sample filter weight change in all but seven of the blanks used. Seven blanks were not included because their weight change (from a negative -90 milligrams (mg) to 5.99 mg) was greater than the limits shown in this graph (-0.2 mg to 0.5 mg). The vertical axis represents the number of blanks that had a weight change within 0.01 mg of the weight change shown on the horizontal axis.

The dashed vertical lines show the upper and lower limits of detection expected for this method (+/ 0.03 mg). The distance between limits of detection represents the maximum weight gain expected for the blanks if the entire sampling procedure was followed as required by standard sampling methodologies. All of the size fractions had at least two blanks outside the limit of detection boundaries. (The two out of range blanks for PM100 are not shown on the graph because they are also beyond the boundaries of the graph). Approximately 6% of the PM100, 70% of the PM10, 57% of the PM4, and 8% of the PM2.5 blanks had weight changes greater than the limit of detection.

In general, blanks are used (1) to assess the ability of the sampling and laboratory analysis methodology to accurately estimate the concentration of particulate matter in the air at the sampled location and (2) to validate that there is no filter contamination problem from the time the blanks are initially weighed in the laboratory until the time the blanks are weighed in the laboratory after sampling. Errors could occur at any step in the process.

The large weight change of the blanks indicates errors in either the laboratory weighing process or the air sampling process. The graph illustrates that the results of the airborne particulate matter sampling cannot be used to reliably estimate the actual concentration of any of the particulate matter size fractions; therefore, the entire data set was rejected from further consideration.

Appendix B.  Survey Result

Summary of Residential Sampling Survey Form Results and Review of Photographs

(Abbreviations and terms used in the table are defined on the last page in this table.)

 

Event Number

 

Location

 

Number of Broken Windows

 

Dust Visible Initially

 

Dust Visible Currently

 

Residence Occupied

 

Cleaning Method

 

Aggressive Sampling

 

Level of Dust in Photo

 

Photo Comments

 

1

 

Outside

 

28

 
         

None Visible

 
 

1

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

Prepared for asbestos abatement

 

1

 

Residence 1

 

2

 

LI

 

Y

 

U

 

None

 

N

 

Large Amount

 

Large amount of WTC dust; more than other locations sampled

 

1

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

U

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

2

 

Outside

 

1

 
 

Y

 
     

None Visible

 
 

2

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

Slight Amount

 
 

2

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 

Residence window faces WTC site

 

2

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

U

 

C

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

3

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Sampled from courtyard several floors up

 

3

 

Common

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 
 

AA

 
 

None Visible

 
 

3

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

AA

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

3

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

4

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

Slight Amount

 
 

4

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

Y

 
 

O

 
 

None Visible

 
 

4

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 

N

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

4

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 

N

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

5

 

Outside

 

50

 
 

Y

 
     

Large Amount

 
 

5

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

AA

 
 

None Visible

 
 

5

 

Residence 1

 

6

 

LI

 

LI

 

Y

 

AA

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

5

 

Residence 2

 

6

 

LI

 

LI

 

Y

 

AA

 

Y

 

None Visible

 

Room looks clean but lots of WTC dust outside one window sill

 

6

 

Outside

 

200

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

6

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
   

Couldn't identify photos for common area

 

6

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

U

 

C

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

6

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

U

 

C

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

7

 

Outside

 

2

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

7

 

Common

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

Many window sills (not sure where) have significant amount of WTC dust  on outside ledge, not noticeable on inside of window.

 

7

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 

7

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 

Resident has window view of WTC site

 

8

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

8

 

Common

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

8

 

Residence 1

 

1

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

8

 

Residence 2

 

1

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 

Resident has window view of WTC site

 

9

 

Outside

 

2

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible in Picture

 

Utility/road construction occurring near building and across the street from the front door.

 

9

 

Common

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

9

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

Y

 

C

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

9

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

Y

 

C

 

Y

 

Slight Amount

 
 

10

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

Y

 
     

Slight Amount

 
 

10

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

AA

 
 

None Visible

 
 

10

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

AA

 

Y

 

None Visible

 

View of Statue of Liberty

 

10

 

Residence 2

 

1

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

AA

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

11

 

Outside

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Looks like many dried, fallen leaves on sidewalk

 

11

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

11

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

V

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

11

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

UNK

 

N

 

V

 

UNK

 

Y

 

None Visible

 

Wall AC unit was removed, it was just a hole to the outside

 

12

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Looks like many dried, fallen leaves on sidewalk

 

12

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

12

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

V

 

None

 

N

 

Large Amount

 

Very messy, doesn't look like WTC dust (has 'post-move-out' look)

 

12

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

V

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

13

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

Slight Amount

 

A little messy, but does not look like WTC dust

 

13

 

Common

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

13

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

V

 

C

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

13

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

V

 

C

 

Y

 

Large Amount

 

Very messy, but not with WTC dust (post-move-out look)

 

14

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Air sample from garden area; no bulk sample taken; WTC dust visible on neighboring building.

 

14

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

14

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

U

 

None

 

Y

 

Large Amount

 

Light dust on floors; one pile of material, could be from remodeling activity

 

14

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

U

 

None

 

Y

 

None Visible

 

Pile of trash swept into center of room; no WTC dust

 

15

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Bulk sample from roof top courtyard,

 

15

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 

 Dust visible in (and sampled from) cracks between tiles.

 

15

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 

U

 

O

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

15

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

U

 

O

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

16

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

16

 

Common

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

16

 

Residence 1

 

0

 
     

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

16

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 
 

No picture

 

17

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

Slight Amount

 

Dirty/messy, but doesn't look like WTC dust

 

17

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

17

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

17

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

U

 

C

 

Y

 

Slight Amount

 
 

18

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

M

 

Sample looks granular and sandy, not gray like WTC dust

 

18

 

Common

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 

Leaf track-in visible

 

18

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 

Window view of WTC site

 

18

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

19

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

Moderate

 

Visible in, and sampled from, sidewalk joint with building; sidewalk looked cleaner.

 

19

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

19

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

19

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 
 

No picture

 

20

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

Unk

 

Too distant to see surface dust

 

20

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

20

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

20

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 
 

No picture

 

21

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

21

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

21

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

21

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

22

 

Outside

 

8

 
 

Y

 
     

None Visible

 

Sidewalk/entrance to building and roof courtyard look clean, but there is a pile of material to sample on roof; location is unknown.

 

22

 

Common

 

1

 

LI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

22

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

Y

 

MS

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

22

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

23

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

23

 

Common

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

23

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

MI

 

Y

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

23

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

24

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

24

 

Common

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

24

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

24

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

25

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

25

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

25

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

25

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

26

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

26

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 

Floor area sampled contained some broken tiles.

 

26

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

26

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

27

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

27

 

Common

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

27

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

LI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

27

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

28

 

Outside

 

0

 
         

None Visible

 

Bulk sample from 4-inch wide strip between two different tiled areas; thick with granular/dusty/other material, not sure if any is WTC.

 

28

 

Common

 

0

 

LI

 

Y

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 

28

 

Residence 1

 

3

 

LI

 

N

 

U

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

28

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

U

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

29

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 

Bulk sample from small pile at an inside corner of the building wall

 

29

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

C

 
 

None Visible

 
 

29

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

29

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

SI

 

Y

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

30

 

Outside

 

0

 
           

No picture

 

30

 

Common

 

0

 
           

No picture

 

30

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

SI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

30

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

MI

 

N

 

Y

 

C

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

31

 

Outside

 

0

 
         

None Visible

 
 

31

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

31

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

N

 

MS

 

Y

 

None Visible

 
 

31

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

NI

 

UNK

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

32

 

Outside

 

0

 
         

None Visible

 

Trash visible on sidewalk

 

32

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

32

 

Residence 1

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

32

 

Residence 2

 

0

 
             

33

 

Outside

 

0

 
         

None Visible

 
 

33

 

Common

 

0

 
             

33

 

Residence 1

 

0

 
             

33

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

NI

 

Y

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

34

 

Outside

 

0

 
 

N

 
     

None Visible

 
 

34

 

Common

 

0

 

NI

 

N

 
 

MS

 
 

None Visible

 
 

34

 

Residence 1

 

0

 
             

34

 

Residence 2

 

0

 

UNK

 

N

 

Y

 

O

 

N

 

None Visible

 
 

AA = asbestos abatement professionals

C = contractor

LI = large increase

M = moderate increase

MS = building management staff

N = no

NI = no Increase

O = owner/tenant

SI = slight increase over normal

UNK = unknown

Y = yes

 


Appendix C.  Detailed Analytic Results

Results of Fiber Analyses

Results of fiber analyses in air and dust samples from 30 residential buildings (130) in lower Manhattan and 4 comparison buildings (3134) above 59th Street. The range of values measured in the comparison buildings is shown in the summary of comparison areas above 59th Street.

Building Number

 

Sample Location

 

Results From Air Samples

 

Results From Dust Samples

 

Fibers in Air PCM (f/cc)

 

Asbestos in Air TEM (f/cc)

 

SVF in Air SEM (f/cc)

 

Asbestos in Dust PLM (%)

 

Asbestos in Dust TEM (%)

 

SVF in Dust PLM (%)

 
               

Summary of Comparison Areas Above 59th Street

 
       
 

Outside

 

<.0010.001

 

NA

 

ND<.000043

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 
 

Common

 

<.0010.002

 

NA

 

ND0.000043

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Residences

 

<.0010.003

 

NA

 

ND0.000087

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

Results for Individual Buildings Sampled in Lower Manhattan (Buildings 130)

 
   

1

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

22

 

1

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

1

 

Residence 1

 

0.006

 

<.001

 

0.000162

 

ND

 

NA

 

20

 

1

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

NA

 

20

 
               

2

 

Outside

 

0.003

 
   

<1

 

1.2

 

28

 

2

 

Outside co-located

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

1.3

 

NA

 

25

 

2

 

Common

 

0.005

 

<.001

 

0.000255

 

ND

 

NA

 

27

 

2

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

NA

 

25

 

2

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

NA

 

20

 

2

 

Window sill

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

<1

 

<1

 

30

 
               

3

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

3

 

Res 2 co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

3

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

3

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

3

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 
               

4

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

4

 

Outside co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

4

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

15

 

4

 

Common co-located

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

4

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

2

 

4

 

Residence 2

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

5

 
               

5

 

Outside

 

0.002

 
   

3.4

 

NA

 

25

 

5

 

Outside co-located

 

0.003

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

5

 

Common

 

0.002

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

5

 

Residence 1

 

0.002

 
   

<1

 

<1

 

10

 

5

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

20

 
               

6

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

6

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

10

 

6

 

Res 2 co-located

 

0.002

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

6

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

6

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

15

 
               

7

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

1.7

 

35

 

7

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

7

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

7

 

Window sill (R2)

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

ND

 

ND

 

40

 
               

8

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

8

 

Common

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Residence 1

 

0.003

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

9

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

9

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

9

 

Common co-located

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

9

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

2

 

9

 

Residence 2

 

0.003

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

5

 
               

10

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Common

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

1.5

 

20

 

10

 

Common, TEM re-analysis

 
     

<1

 
 

10

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

10

 

Residence 2

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

10

 
               

11

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

11

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

11

 

Common co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

11

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

ND

 

11

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

1.5

 

ND

 
               

12

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

12

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

12

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

12

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 
               

13

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

13

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Residence 1

 

0.003

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

13

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

14

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

14

 

Common

 

0.0013

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

14

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

14

 

Res 1 co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

14

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

15

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

1.9

 

72

 

15

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

ND

 

15

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 
               

16

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

1

 

16

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Residence 1

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

16

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Res 2 co-located

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

ND

 

NA

 

ND

 

16

 

Res 2 filter piece

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

ND

 

NA

 

ND

 
               

17

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

17

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

17

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

17

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

18

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

18

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Residence 1

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

18

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

35

 
               

19

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

NA

 

ND

 

19

 

Common

 

overloaded

 

<.006

 
 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

20

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

20

 

Outside co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

20

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

21

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

21

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

22

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

22

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

3

 

22

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

22

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Res 2 co-located

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 
               

23

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

23

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

24

 

Outside

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

55

 

24

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

5

 

24

 

Residence 1

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Residence 2

 

0.005

 

<.001

 

0.000037

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

24

 

Res 2 co-located

 

0.005

 

<.001

 
 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 
               

25

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

25

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

25

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

25

 

Residence 2

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

26

 

Outside

 

0.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

26

 

Common

 

0.004

 

<.001

 

<0.00004

 

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

26

 

Residence 1

 

0.012

 

<.001

 

<0.00004

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

27

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

15

 

27

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

10

 

27

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

<1

 

10

 

27

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

10

 
               

28

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

28

 

Common

 

0.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

28

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

Insufficient Material

 

ND

 

28

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

29

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

30

 

Outside

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

30

 

Common

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

30

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

Results for Comparison Buildings Sampled Above 59th Street (Buildings 3134)

 
 

31

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

31

 

Outside co-located

 

0.001

 
 

0.000039

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

31

 

Common

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

31

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
 

<0.000039

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

31

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
 

<0.000038

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

32

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
 

<0.000039

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

32

 

Common

 

0.002

 
 

<0.00004

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Residence 1

 

<.001

 
   

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Res 1 co-located

 

0.001

 
 

0.000087

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

32

 

Residence 2

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 
               

33

 

Outside

 

Not Sampled

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

33

 

Common

 

Not Sampled

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

33

 

Residence 1

 

Not Sampled

 
   

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

33

 

Residence 2

 

<.001

 
 

<0.000041

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
               

34

 

Outside

 

<.001

 
 

<0.000043

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

34

 

Common

 

<.001

 
 

0.000043

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Residence 1

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

34

 

Residence 2

 

0.002

 
   

ND

 

Insuf. Material

 

ND

 

34

 

Res 2 co-located

 

0.003

 
 

<0.000047

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

Not Sampled

 

f/cc:     fibers per cubic centimeter of air

NA:      not analyzed

ND:      not detected

PCM:   phase contrast microscopy

PLM:   polarized light microscopy

SEM:   scanning electron microscopy

SVF:    synthetic vitreous fibers

TEM:   transmission electron microscopy

%:         percent

Results of Mineral Analyses in Dust and Air

 

The following table shows the results of analyses of the minerals in settled dust and air samples for 30 residential buildings in lower Manhattan (130) and 4 comparison buildings (31-34) above 59th Street. For each building, the table shows the highest estimated air concentration of mineral for each size fraction. In addition, estimated levels of each mineral in the settled surface dust are shown for each sampled location within a building.

Building Number

 

Sample Type

 

Method or Location

 

Quartz

 

Cristobalite

 

Tridymite

 

Calcite

 

Portlandite

 

Gypsum

 

Mica

 

Halite

 
                     

Summary of Comparison Areas Above 59th Street

 
             
 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common Area

 

ND1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND0.4 J

 

ND0.05 J

 

ND3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 
 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1&2

 

ND2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND0.9 J

 

ND0.08 J

 

24 J

 

ND0.08 J

 

ND0.4 J

 
                     

Results for Individual Buildings Sampled in Lower Manhattan (Buildings 130)

 
       

1

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

6 J

 

84 J

 

12 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

1

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

1

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

27 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15 J

 

6 J

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

19 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

18 J

 

2 J

 

30 J

 

0.3 J

 

ND

 

1

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

31 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

21 J

 

6 J

 

4 J

 

0.05 J

 

ND

 
                     

2

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

7J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

2

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

21 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

19 J

 

3 J

 

27 J

 

ND

 

<0.03 J

 

2

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

0.9 J

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

23 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15 J

 

4 J

 

9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

3

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

24 J

 

5 J

 

13 J

 

ND

 

3

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

25 J

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

3

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

6 J

 

26 J

 

7 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

3

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

3

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

3

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

3

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

3

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 
                     

4

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

4 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

9 J

 

5 J

 

4

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

3 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

ND

 

4 J

 

4

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

6 J

 

28 J

 

5 J

 

14 J

 

8 J

 

4

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

4

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.4 J

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

4

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

4

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

0.2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.06 J

 

0.7 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

4

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

2 J

 

9 J

 

ND

 

0.1 J

 
                     

5

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

14 J

 

95 J

 

14 J

 

ND

 

14 J

 

5

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

15 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

5

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

5

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

23 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

5

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

11 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

4 J

 

0.5 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

6

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

6

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

6

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

6

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

6

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

17 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

10 J

 

3 J

 

20 J

 

0.6 J

 

ND

 

6

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

6

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

27 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

17 J

 

8 J

 

13 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

6

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

24 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15 J

 

4 J

 

4 J

 

0.03 J

 

ND

 
                     

7

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

8 J

 

54 J

 

10 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

11 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

11 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

7

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

11 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8 J

 

3 J

 

15 J

 

0.09 J

 

0.04 J

 

7

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

7 J

 

1 J

 

12 J

 

ND

 

0.1 J

 

7

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13 J

 

2 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

7

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

21 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

4 J

 

ND

 

0.09 J

 

7

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2-co

 

18 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9 J

 

1 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

8

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

7 J

 

ND

 

10 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

6 J

 

ND

 

12 J

 

43 J

 

19 J

 

8

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

8

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

19 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9 J

 

2 J

 

15 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

8

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

15 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

10 J

 

3 J

 

17 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

8

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

28 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

21 J

 

4 J

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

9

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

4 J

 

ND

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

9

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

9

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

25 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9 J

 

4 J

 

16 J

 

0.09 J

 

0.06 J

 

9

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

9

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

10 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

0.9 J

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

9

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

10

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

10

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area-co

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

10

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

21 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

14 J

 

3 J

 

5 J

 

0.09 J

 

0.05 J

 

10

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.06 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

10

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.8 J

 

ND

 

0.04 J

 
                     

11

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

11

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

11

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

11

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

0.2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.02 J

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

11

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

12

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

18 J

 

4 J

 

8 J

 

5 J

 

12

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

7 J

 

28 J

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

7 J

 

12

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

3 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

12

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

12

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

0.4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.09 J

 

0.06 J

 

0.8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

13

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

7 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

10 J

 

26 J

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

13

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.05 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.3 J

 

0.04 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

13

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

13

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

14

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

14

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

14

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

14

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

14

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.03 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

0.04 J

 

14

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

14

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

14

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.08 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

15

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

3 J

 

18 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

15

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.02 J

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.3 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

15

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

16

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

3 J

 

17 J

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

18 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

27 J

 

7 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

16

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.09 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.6 J

 

0.04 J

 

0.06 J

 

0.04 J

 

16

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

16

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

16

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

R2 filter piece

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.3 J

 

0.4 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

17

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

17

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

12 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

4 J

 

17 J

 

6 J

 

ND

 

5 J

 

17

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

27 J

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

ND

 

17

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

17

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.06 J

 

ND

 

17

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

17

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.05 J

 

2 J

 

0.05 J

 

0.03 J

 

17

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.8 J

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

18

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

18

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

7 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.2 J

 

ND

 

18

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

18

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

19

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

19

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.08 J

 

0.05 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.6 J

 

1 J

 

0.09 J

 

0.04 J

 

19

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

19

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

20

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

3 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

3 J

 

16 J

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

5 J

 

29 J

 

6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

20

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

0.04 J

 

20

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

20

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

0.05 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

20

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.6 J

 

0.09 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

0.05 J

 
                     

21

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

21

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

21

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

21

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

22

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

13 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

14 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

26 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

0.8 J

 

0.03 J

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

22

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.07 J

 

0.08 J

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

22

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

0.6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

23

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.04 J

 

0.05 J

 

0.9 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

23

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

23

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

24

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.03 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.8 J

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

0.05 J

 

0.04 J

 

24

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

24

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

25

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

25

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

25

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

25

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

25

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

25

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

25

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

25

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

26

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.7 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

0.6 J

 

2 J

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

26

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

26

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

26

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.05 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

27

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

0.04 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.02 J

 

ND

 

0.1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

0.8 J

 

0.04 J

 

0.07 J

 

ND

 

27

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

27

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

28

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

4 J

 

28

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

28

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

28

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

28

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

28

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

2 J

 

0.3 J

 

0.09 J

 

ND

 

28

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

28

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

29

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

19 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.09 J

 

0.06 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

8 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

2 J

 

2 J

 

0.3 J

 

0.07 J

 

29

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

0.2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

29

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

30

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

30

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

30

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

30

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

30

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.9 J

 

4 J

 

0.06 J

 

0.05 J

 

30

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

0.6 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.4 J

 

0.4 J

 

4 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

Results for Individual Comparison Buildings Sampled Above 59th Street (Buildings 3134)

 
   
 

31

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

31

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

31

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

31

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

31

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.03 J

 

0.05 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

0.04 J

 

31

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

31

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

31

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

32

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

5 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.4 J

 

ND

 

3J

 

ND

 

ND

 

32

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

32

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.9 J

 

0.08 J

 

4 J

 

0.08 J

 

0.4 J

 

32

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 
                     

33

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

33

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

33

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

33

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

33

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

33

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

33

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

33

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

1 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

0.08 J

 

2 J

 

ND

 

ND

 
                     

34

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM100

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM10

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM4

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Air (g/m3)

 

PM2.5

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Common area

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

34

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Outdoor

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

34

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 1

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

34

 

Settled surface dust (%)

 

Residence 2

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

ND

 

3 J

 

ND

 

ND

 

ASN:  Analytical sensitivity not available. Mineral was not detected at any measured location using the associated method, analytical sensitivity is not known.

Detect:  Mineral was detected above the analytical sensitivity in at least one of the measured locations of the building using the associated method.

J:  Estimated value. Due to inconsistencies during sample collection/analysis, the result is only an estimate of the actual value. The actual value could be higher or lower than the value shown.

ND:  Not detected. Mineral was not detected at any measured location using the associated method.

NS:  Not sampled. The associated method was not used at any of the measured locations in the building.

R:  Result was rejected. Due to inconsistencies during sample collection/analysis, the result values for the sample were rejected.

mg/m3:  microgram per cubic meter of air.

Mineral Analyses in Air

 

Estimated levels of minerals in air for samples from 30 residential buildings (130) in lower Manhattan and 4 comparison residential buildings (3134) above 59th Street are shown in the following table. The estimated air concentration of each mineral by size fraction is shown for each area sampled. Typically, samples were obtained from an outdoor area, an indoor common area, and two residences. In addition, co-located samples were obtained from some locations. However, due to inconsistencies during sample collection or analysis, the specific sampling location within the building is not noted.

Building Number

 

Particle Size Fraction

 

Sample Volume (L)

 

Quartz

(μg/m3)

 

Cristobalite

(μg/m3)

 

Tridymite

(μg/m3)

 

Calcite

μg/m3)

 

Portlandite (μg/m3)

 

Gypsum

(μg/m3)

 

Mica

μg/m3)

 

Halite

(μg/m3))

 
                     

Summary of Comparison Areas Above 59th Street

 
           
 

PM100

 
 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

ND3 J

 

--

 

--

 
 

PM10

 
 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

ND3 J

 

--

 

--

 
 

PM4

 
 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

ND5 J

 

--

 

--

 
 

PM2.5

 
 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

ND3 J

 

--

 

--

 
                     

Results for Individual Buildings Sampled in Lower Manhattan (Buildings 130)

 
       

1

 

PM100

 

882

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM100

 

830

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM100

 

818

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM100

 

892

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM10

 

861

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM10

 

835

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM10

 

838

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM10

 

899

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM4

 

809

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

84 J

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM4

 

813

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

12 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM4

 

820

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

68 J

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

1

 

PM4

 

837

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

2

 

PM100

 

1229

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM100

 

1162

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM100

 

766

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM100

 

1240

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
 

--

 

2

 

PM10

 

1194

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM10

 

1168

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM10

 

1390

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM10

 

1216

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM4

 

757

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7J

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM4

 

717

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM4

 

849

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

2

 

PM4

 

762

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

3

 

PM100

 

868

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM100

 

821

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

--

 

5 J

 

24 J

 

5 J

 

13 J

 

--

 

3

 

PM100

 

756

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM100

 

761

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM10

 

858

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM10

 

815

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

5J

 

25 J

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM10

 

765

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM10

 

783

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM4

 

814

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM4

 

824

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

26 J

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM4

 

841

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

3

 

PM4

 

823

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

4

 

PM100

 

1230

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM100

 

1289

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

9 J

 

5J

 

4

 

PM100

 

1278

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM100

 

1221

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

5J

 

4

 

PM10

 

1218

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM10

 

1415

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

4J

 

4

 

PM10

 

1294

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM10

 

1201

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM4

 

751

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

27J

 

5J

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM4

 

793

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

6J

 

28J

 

5J

 

14 J

 

8 J

 

4

 

PM4

 

804

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

4

 

PM4

 

757

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

5

 

PM100

 

783

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14 J

 

95 J

 

14 J

 

--

 

14 J

 

5

 

PM100

 

786

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM100

 

804

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM100

 

800

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM10

 

780

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM10

 

797

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM10

 

846

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14 J

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM10

 

789

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM4

 

817

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM4

 

664

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM4

 

813

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9 J

 

--

 

--

 

5

 

PM4

 

813

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15 J

 

--

 

--

 
                     

6

 

PM100

 

1241

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM100

 

1212

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM100

 

1238

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

6

 

PM10

 

1226

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM10

 

1197

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM10

 

1252

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM10

 

1254

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM4

 

775

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM4

 

762

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM4

 

775

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6

 

PM4

 

772

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

7

 

PM100

 

1277

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM100

 

1260

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8 J

 

54 J

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM100

 

1243

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM100

 

1213

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM10

 

1227

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM10

 

1225

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11 J

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM10

 

1240

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM10

 

1231

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM4

 

787

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM4

 

784

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM4

 

765

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11 J

 

--

 

--

 

7

 

PM4

 

748

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

8

 

PM100

 

1213

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7 J

 

--

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM100

 

1254

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM100

 

1223

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM100

 

1206

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM100

 

1175

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM100

 

1259

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM10

 

1188

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM10

 

1223

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM10

 

1172

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM10

 

1256

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM4

 

757

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

12 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM4

 

784

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

10 J

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM4

 

738

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8

 

PM4

 

777

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10J

 

43J

 

19 J

 
                     

9

 

PM100

 

1210

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM100

 

1218

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

9

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

9

 

PM10

 

1203

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM10

 

1217

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

--

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM10

 

1231

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM10

 

1131

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM4

 

776

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM4

 

782

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM4

 

763

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

9

 

PM4

 

781

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

10

 

PM100

 

1201

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM100

 

1225

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM100

 

1220

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM100

 

1226

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM10

 

1181

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM10

 

1202

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM10

 

1227

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM10

 

1224

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM4

 

757

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM4

 

766

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM4

 

762

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

8 J

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

10

 

PM4

 

767

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

11

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

11

 

PM10

 

1305

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM10

 

1301

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM10

 

1337

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM10

 

1237

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM4

 

832

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM4

 

806

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM4

 

834

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

11

 

PM4

 

779

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

12

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

PM100

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

NS

 

12

 

PM10

 

1412

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

14 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

12

 

PM10

 

1315

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

18 J

 

4 J

 

8 J

 

5 J

 

12

 

PM10

 

1337

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

17 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

5 J

 

12

 

PM10

 

1553

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

12

 

PM10

 

1479

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

12

 

PM4

 

925

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

22 J

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

12

 

PM4

 

828

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

7 J

 

28 J

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

7 J

 

12

 

PM4

 

948

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

12

 

PM4

 

932

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 
                     

13

 

PM100

 

1281

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1300

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1298

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1284

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1211

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1203

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM100

 

1184

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM10

 

1263

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM10

 

1325

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM10

 

1223

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM10

 

1205

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM4

 

802

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM4

 

818

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

10 J

 

26 J

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM4

 

762

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

13

 

PM4

 

761

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

14

 

PM100

 

1151

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM100

 

1169

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM100

 

1166

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM100

 

1142

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM100

 

1171

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM100

 

1149

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM10

 

1134

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM10

 

1138

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM10

 

1155

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM10

 

1179

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM10

 

1161

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM4

 

719

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM4

 

731

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM4

 

732

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

14

 

PM4

 

730

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

15

 

PM100

 

1219

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM100

 

1199

 

8 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

18 J

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM100

 

1211

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM100

 

1156

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM10

 

1218

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM10

 

1115

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

R

 

15

 

PM10

 

1212

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM10

 

1225

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM10

 

1171

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM4

 

783

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM4

 

778

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM4

 

766

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

15

 

PM4

 

751

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

16

 

PM100

 

1254

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM100

 

1225

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

17 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM100

 

1217

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM10

 

1269

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM10

 

1228

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM10

 

1210

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM4

 

808

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM4

 

774

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM4

 

769

 

18 J

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

27 J

 

7 J

 

--

 

--

 

16

 

PM4

 

769

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 
                     

17

 

PM10

 

1306

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM10

 

1469

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

16 J

 

3 J

 

--

 

4 J

 

17

 

PM10

 

1250

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM10

 

1259

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM10

 

1293

 

12 J

 

--

 

--

 

4 J

 

17 J

 

6 J

 

--

 

5 J

 

17

 

PM4

 

844

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM4

 

816

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

27 J

 

6 J

 

15 J

 

--

 

17

 

PM4

 

786

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM4

 

786

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

5 J

 

--

 

--

 

17

 

PM4

 

803

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

26 J

 

6 J

 

--

 

--

 
                     

18

 

PM100

 

1277

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM100

 

1247

 

3 J

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM100

 

1241

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM100

 

1265

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM100

 

1177

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM10

 

1234

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM10

 

1269

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM10

 

1258

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM10

 

1268

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

18

 

PM10

 

1196

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

--

 

3 J

 

--

 

--