Media Announcements - Minot, ND
Former Employees and Household Members Face Possible Elevated Health Risks from Asbestos Contact
No Apparent Public Health Hazard to Current Area Workers and Residents
For Immediate Release: Sept. 17, 2003
ATLANTA - A public health consultation of the former Robinson Insulation Company facility in Minot, N.D., by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) concludes that facility employees were exposed to elevated levels of asbestos. Residents of employees' households also may have been exposed to asbestos fibers brought into the household on employees' clothing, skin and hair. Therefore, employees and those who lived in their homes may be at increased risk of asbestos-related diseases.
ATSDR, a public health agency of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, recommends that former employees of this facility and those who lived in their households learn more about asbestos and see a physician regarding potentially adverse health effects.
"Because of the elevated health risk, ATSDR believes former Robinson Insulation employees and members of their households should seek medical follow-up," stated Vikas Kapil, M.D., a specialist in occupational and environmental medicine with ATSDR. "We encourage them to consult with a physician with expertise in the evaluation and management of asbestos-related lung disease."
From 1945 to 1983, the plant, located at 826 Fourth Ave., N.E., processed tons of asbestos-contaminated vermiculite ore mined in Libby, Mont. The vermiculite was exfoliated (heated until it expanded, or "popped"), then used to manufacture other products.
In 1993 the Minot Parks Department purchased the property and used the two former processing buildings to store equipment. At one time, residences were located directly across the street from the east side of the processing buildings. These houses, however, have been demolished. Currently, the nearest homes lie approximately 500 feet south of the site of the former processing buildings.
From June 2001 through April 2002, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) collected hundreds of environmental samples at the site and at selected locations near the site. Sample results indicated some residual Libby asbestos within the former processing buildings, in soils at the site, and at several locations nearby. Under EPA supervision, the former processing buildings were torn down. Soils containing asbestos were removed and replaced with clean fill. This cleanup was completed in December 2002.
Because of the EPA clean-up, exposure to asbestos does not appear to pose a public health hazard to those now employed at the site or living or working in the surrounding area.
Information about what occurred during the period when the plant processed the asbestos-contaminated vermiculite remains incomplete. Whether people living near the site when it was in operation were exposed to asbestos is not known. Also unknown is whether those currently living nearby are being exposed to asbestos from "stoner rock" (un-popped vermiculite), a process waste product which may have been used in the community for various purposes such as fill, driveway surfacing or soil amendments.
The vermiculite ore processed in Minot contained asbestos, which can become airborne and can be inhaled. Exposure to asbestos fibers is associated with serious adverse human health effects, including lung cancer, mesothelioma and asbestosis, a disorder that restricts breathing capacity. Because of the effects associated with asbestos exposure, ATSDR continues a broad range of efforts in Libby and is expanding those efforts to include sites that received and processed Libby ore.
National Asbestos Exposure Review
The Minot site is part of ATSDR's National Asbestos Exposure Review (NAER), being conducted in two phases with other federal, state and local environmental and public health agencies. NAER is an examination of more than 200 sites around the U.S. that received asbestos-contaminated vermiculite ore mined in Libby from the early 1920s until 1990. ATSDR is working closely with EPA and state health partners to determine if a hazard to public health exists at any of the sites.
Phase One of NAER includes an examination of 28 sites chosen because either they were on the EPA "further action" list or they were an exfoliation facility that processed over 100,000 tons of vermiculite from the Libby mine. The Phase One sites received 80 percent of the total tonnage of vermiculite ore shipped from Libby from 1964 to 1990.
The NAER team is working to achieve the following goals:
- Evaluate the 28 Phase One sites to identify past and present exposure pathways (ways people could have been exposed to asbestos from contaminated vermiculite);
- Evaluate exposure pathways to determine if a significant public health hazard exists and what actions are necessary to protect public health; and
- Formulate a plan to determine public health actions at sites not considered in the Phase One evaluation.
The NAER team is working with participating states to ensure national consistency in the evaluations, facilitate health consultations for those sites without a state lead, and compile findings in a comprehensive report. An overview of the first 28 sites will be released by year-end 2004.
The public health consultation and fact sheet for the Minot site may be reviewed in person at the following location:
Minot Public Library, 516 2nd Ave. SW (Telephone: 701-852-1045)
Public input and questions are encouraged. ATSDR responses will be provided in a comprehensive report that incorporates findings from all 28 sites, and not as an additional release of this site-specific health consultation. Comments on the health consultation must be submitted in writing by Oct. 31, 2003. Mail comments to:
Chief, Program Evaluation, Records and Information Services Branch
1600 Clifton Rd., NE (MS E-60)
Atlanta, GA 30333
The names of those who submit comments will not be printed in a public document. They are, however, subject to release through requests made under the U.S. Freedom of Information Act.
Community members seeking information on the procedures or the content of the health consultation, or copies of the document, may contact Maria Teran-MacIver or Debra Joseph, community involvement specialists, toll free at 1-888-422-8737. Callers should refer to the Minot site.
Further information regarding asbestos and the 28 sites being reviewed is available at the local repository listed above.
Members of the news media may request an interview with ATSDR staff by calling Elaine McEachern or Scott Mall in the ATSDR Office of Policy and External Affairs at 404-498-0070.
- Page last reviewed: January 20, 2009
- Page last updated: January 20, 2009
- Content source: Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry