Although the pathways for metabolism of TCE in mice, rats, and humans appear to be qualitatively similar, quantitatively differences among species may substantially alter the effective dose of reactive metabolite(s) that is delivered to a target organ (Bruckner, Davis et al. 1989).
It has been estimated that humans metabolize approximately 20 times less TCE on a body weight basis than rats at similar exposure levels. Consequently, humans metabolize approximately 60 times less TCE on a body weight basis than mice (Goeptar, Commandeur et al. 1995).
Species differences in TCE metabolism might explain observed differences in susceptibility to specific TCE-related diseases. Liver cancer, for example, occurs mainly in strains of mice that generate high levels of trichloroacetic and dichloroacetic acids as TCE metabolites in liver cells. By contrast, rats that metabolize more TCE via glutathione conjugation are prone to renal cancer.
Because of such species-specific effects, caution must be used when extrapolating adverse effects from experimental animals to humans (Kimbrough, Mitchell et al. 1985; Fan 1988; Goeptar, Commandeur et al. 1995; Kaneko, Wang et al. 1997; Lash, Fisher et al. 2000). |