Part 4: The Cholinergic Toxidrome
Section 5: Signs and Symptoms by Route of Exposure and Chemical Structure of the Involved Cholinesterase Inhibitor (Optional Reading)
- Learning Objectives (Optional Reading)
- Signs and Symptoms by Route of Exposure (Optional Reading)
- Chemical Structure versus Toxicity (Optional Reading)
- Vapor Exposure
- Dermal Exposure
- Oral Exposure (Optional Reading
- Reasons for Delayed Onset of Clinical Findings (Optional Reading)
- Key Points (Optional Reading)
Course: WB 1098
CE Original Date: October 16, 2007
CE Renewal Date: October 16, 2010
CE Expiration Date: October 16, 2012
Download Printer-Friendly Version pdf icon[PDF – 1.88MB]
Upon completion of this portion of the case study, the learner should be able to describe how:
- Signs and symptoms of cholinesterase toxicity vary with the route of exposure.
- Cholinesterase toxicity relates to the chemical structure of the cholinesterase inhibitors.
Cholinesterase inhibitors may be rapidly absorbed via dermal, conjunctival, respiratory, and gastrointestinal routes. (Carlton, Simpson et al. 1998) Other factors being equal (e.g., chemical structure), signs and symptoms may vary by route of exposure (although any constellation of findings can occur with significant exposure by any route). (Sidell 1997; Carlton, Simpson et al. 1998; Leikin, Thomas et al. 2002; Erdman 2004)
|Exposure Route||Rapidity of Onset of Clinical Findings|
|Inhalation||the most rapid (seconds to minutes)|
|Ingestion||intermediate (typically within 30-90 minutes)|
|Dermal||the slowest (may be up to 18 hours)|
Note: Very high doses of nerve agents can act within minutes, even with dermal exposures. (Sidell 1997)
Among other factors, the toxicity of cholinesterase inhibitors varies with chemical structure.
For example: (Besser and Gutmann 1994)
- Organophosphorus compounds having a quaternary nitrogen (ammonium) attached to the phosphorus atom have the highest toxicity.
- Also very toxic are those containing an attached fluorine atom (This includes the chemical warfare nerve agents).
- Less toxic are those containing a cyanide or halogen other than fluorine.
- Less toxic still are those with attached alkyl, alkoxy, alkylthio, aryloxy, arylthio, heterocyclic analogs, or nonquaternary nitrogen. Most organophosphorus compounds belong to this category.
Note: Mild vapor exposure may produce eye and respiratory symptoms due to localized tissue contact even in the absence of other systemic findings.
With dermal exposure to nerve agents onset of clinical findings of the cholinergic toxidrome may be delayed up to 18 hours. (Sidell 1997) Thus, patients with suspected dermal exposure should be observed and monitored. No definite minimum, safe duration of observation has yet been established because of lack of clinical experience and clinical studies. (Leikin, Thomas et al. 2002)
Respiratory symptoms may be absent in mild to moderate exposures. (Leikin, Thomas et al. 2002)
A substantial proportion of those with isolated dermal exposure do not develop miosis (pupillary constriction). (Sidell 1997)
The frequency and sequence of clinical findings after ingesting cholinesterase inhibitors have received less attention in the literature. Generally, with this route, gastrointestinal signs and symptoms are the first to appear. (Carlton, Simpson et al. 1998; Tareg, B et al. 2001; Erdman 2004)
- Abdominal cramps.
Note: Cholinesterase inhibiting insecticides are often dissolved in hydrocarbons, and ingestion may be associated with pulmonary aspiration and chemical pneumonitis, as well as a solvent-like breath odor. (Durham and Hayes 1962; Clark 2002)
Delayed onset may occur with:
- Dermal exposure.
- Cholinesterase inhibitors which can be stored in fat tissue and released over time (e.g., dichlofenthion). (Clark 2002)
- Cholinesterase inhibitors whose toxicity requires metabolic conversion (e.g., malathion).
Note: In some cases, deceptively mild initial symptoms may be followed by a rapid worsening up to 48 hours later. This may occur even while the patient is undergoing antidotal treatment. (Erdman 2004)
- Cholinesterase inhibitors may be rapidly absorbed via dermal, conjunctival, respiratory, and gastrointestinal routes.